Traub's Bakery Is Back! Menu, Reviews, & More In Prospect Park

16 May, 2025

Craving a taste of nostalgia, a sugar rush that takes you back to simpler times? Prospect Park's beloved Traub's Bakery, a name synonymous with delectable treats and community spirit, is more than just a bakery; it's a landmark woven into the fabric of local life.

For generations, Traub's Bakery has been a cornerstone of Prospect Park, Pennsylvania, a place where the aroma of freshly baked goods fills the air and sweet memories are made. Located at 1020 Lincoln Ave, Prospect Park, PA 19076, this bakery has garnered a loyal following, evident in the numerous positive reviews and high ratings it has consistently received. While the name above the door may now read "Keystone Bakery," the legacy of Traub's Bakery remains, a testament to the enduring appeal of quality baking and community connection. Recent years haven't been without their challenges, including a temporary closure due to sanitation concerns. However, the bakery's resilience shines through, as it has reopened its doors, eager to continue serving the community with its classic offerings.

Category	Information
Name	Legacy: Traub's Bakery, Currently: Keystone Bakery
Location	1020 Lincoln Ave, Prospect Park, Pennsylvania 19076
Cuisine	Bakery, Coffee Shop, Donuts
Rating	4.0 - 4.3 (Based on TripAdvisor and Restaurant Guru reviews)
Price Range	$ (Budget-friendly)
Menu Highlights	Cakes, Custom Cakes, Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, Specialty Cupcakes, Brownies, NY Style Cannolis, Cannolis, Pies
Key Attributes	Long-standing local bakery, known for quality and community connection.
Reference Link	TripAdvisor (Search for "Traub's Bakery Prospect Park" or "Keystone Bakery Prospect Park" for reviews)

The heart of Traub's Bakery, past and present, lies in its commitment to crafting irresistible treats. The menu boasts a tempting array of classic baked goods. From elaborate custom cakes perfect for special occasions to the simple pleasure of a warm donut, Traub's Bakery caters to a wide range of tastes. Cheesecakes, cupcakes (both regular and specialty), cupcake cakes, brownies, and an assortment of cannolis – including the iconic NY style – are just a few of the delights awaiting patrons. Pies, another staple, round out the selection, offering a comforting and familiar taste of home.

The reviews speak volumes about the bakery's enduring appeal. With an average rating hovering around 4.2 out of 5 on platforms like TripAdvisor and Restaurant Guru, Traub's Bakery consistently earns praise for its quality, taste, and friendly service. Ranked among the top restaurants in Prospect Park, it's a testament to its popularity and the high regard in which it's held by the local community. The closure and subsequent reopening of the bakery due to health department concerns understandably raised eyebrows, but it also highlighted the community's unwavering support. The fact that it bounced back so quickly underscores its importance to Prospect Park.

More than just a place to satisfy a sweet tooth, Traub's Bakery serves as a social hub, a meeting place where neighbors gather, friends catch up, and families create lasting memories. The warm and inviting atmosphere, coupled with the delicious aromas emanating from the ovens, creates an experience that transcends the simple act of buying baked goods. It's a place where you can feel a sense of connection, a feeling of belonging to a community that values tradition, quality, and the simple pleasures of life.

While the name may have changed to Keystone Bakery, the essence of Traub's Bakery remains. The same recipes, the same dedication to quality, and the same commitment to the community are still evident in every cake, cupcake, and cannoli. Whether you're a long-time resident of Prospect Park or a visitor passing through, a trip to Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is a must. It's an opportunity to experience a taste of local history, to indulge in some truly delicious treats, and to support a business that has been a vital part of the community for generations.

Beyond the traditional baked goods, Traub's Bakery likely offered (and Keystone Bakery continues to offer) a variety of coffee and other beverages, making it a convenient stop for a quick breakfast, a mid-afternoon pick-me-up, or a sweet treat to enjoy with friends. The combination of bakery and coffee shop creates a welcoming environment where customers can linger, relax, and savor the moment. The presence of donut shops in the surrounding Delaware County area further emphasizes the region's appreciation for sweet treats, solidifying Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery)'s position as a key player in the local culinary landscape.

The availability of menus, reviews, maps, and delivery information online makes it easier than ever to discover and enjoy the offerings of Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery). Whether you're looking for a custom cake for a special occasion, a box of assorted pastries for a party, or simply a single donut to satisfy a craving, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is ready to meet your needs. The positive reviews and high ratings are a testament to its consistent quality and commitment to customer satisfaction. Despite any past challenges, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) remains a beloved institution in Prospect Park, a place where the tradition of delicious baking continues to thrive.

Considering alternatives in the area, such as Yum Cha Bubble Tea and Hallow Bamboo Jamaican Cuisine, highlights the diverse culinary scene in Prospect Park. While these establishments offer unique and appealing options, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) stands out for its long-standing tradition and its focus on classic baked goods. Yum Cha Bubble Tea, with its tea, bakery items, and coffee, provides a different kind of sweet treat experience, while Hallow Bamboo Jamaican Cuisine offers a savory alternative with its seafood, Caribbean dishes, and wings. However, for those seeking the familiar comfort of a classic bakery, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) remains the go-to destination.

The location of Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) at 1020 Lincoln Ave places it in a central and accessible part of Prospect Park. This convenient location has undoubtedly contributed to its popularity and its ability to serve the community effectively. The presence of nearby places, as indicated by the mention of checking out nearby places on a map, further enhances the bakery's accessibility and its integration into the local landscape. Whether you're a resident running errands or a visitor exploring the area, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is easily accessible and ready to welcome you with its delicious treats.

Ultimately, the story of Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is a story of community, tradition, and the enduring appeal of delicious baked goods. Despite changes in ownership and temporary setbacks, the bakery has remained a vital part of Prospect Park, a place where memories are made and sweet cravings are satisfied. The positive reviews, the high ratings, and the unwavering support of the community are all testaments to its enduring legacy. So, the next time you're in Prospect Park, be sure to stop by Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) and experience the magic for yourself. You won't be disappointed.

The reviews consistently highlight the quality and taste of the baked goods, with many customers praising the cakes, cupcakes, and cannolis in particular. The use of high-quality ingredients and traditional baking methods likely contributes to the bakery's success and its ability to consistently deliver delicious treats. The dedication to craftsmanship and the attention to detail are evident in every item, making Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) a true gem in the Prospect Park culinary scene.

The fact that Traub's Bakery has reopened after a temporary closure due to sanitation violations speaks volumes about its commitment to improvement and its willingness to address any concerns. The bakery's management has clearly taken steps to ensure that it meets the highest standards of cleanliness and hygiene, reassuring customers and reaffirming its dedication to providing a safe and enjoyable experience. This commitment to quality and safety further strengthens Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery)'s position as a trusted and reliable establishment in the community.

The availability of ice cream and frozen desserts in addition to baked goods further expands the appeal of Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery), making it a destination for a wider range of treats and cravings. Whether you're in the mood for a scoop of ice cream on a hot day or a warm brownie with a dollop of whipped cream, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. This versatility and adaptability have undoubtedly contributed to its long-term success and its ability to remain relevant in a constantly evolving culinary landscape.

The consistent ranking of Traub's Bakery among the top restaurants in Prospect Park, despite the presence of other dining options, underscores its unique appeal and its ability to stand out from the crowd. While other establishments may offer different cuisines and dining experiences, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) remains a beloved institution, a place where the tradition of delicious baking continues to thrive. Its enduring legacy and its unwavering commitment to quality make it a true treasure in the Prospect Park community.

In conclusion, Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is more than just a bakery; it's a symbol of community, tradition, and the enduring power of delicious baked goods. Its long history, its unwavering commitment to quality, and its dedication to customer satisfaction have made it a beloved institution in Prospect Park. Whether you're a long-time resident or a visitor passing through, a trip to Traub's Bakery (Keystone Bakery) is a must. It's an opportunity to experience a taste of local history, to indulge in some truly irresistible treats, and to support a business that has been a vital part of the community for generations.

TRAUB'S BAKERY, Prospect Park Restaurant Reviews, Photos & Phone

Details

Detail Author:

Name : Miss Delilah Runolfsson MD
Username : thowe
Email : tevin.mayert@mante.com
Birthdate : 2006-12-30
Address : 698 Corkery Canyon Stoltenbergmouth, PA 14878-7684
Phone : 1-786-420-7144
Company : Rath, Gislason and Becker
Job : Diagnostic Medical Sonographer
Bio : Non accusamus perspiciatis adipisci. Voluptatibus qui quas maxime. Natus aliquam id quia autem. Numquam omnis ut id quo.

Socials

twitter:

url : https://twitter.com/carter1982
username : carter1982
bio : Odit eveniet quae sed itaque. Quia qui eos corrupti dolore qui aut vitae. Pariatur nihil explicabo nesciunt maxime officia.
followers : 4023
following : 2870

tiktok:

url : https://tiktok.com/@dalton2506
username : dalton2506
bio : Provident in et ad. Veritatis inventore et iure.
followers : 807
following : 1237

facebook:

url : https://facebook.com/dalton4979
username : dalton4979
bio : Eum aut molestiae nisi maxime quia laudantium porro.
followers : 4466
following : 995

instagram:

url : https://instagram.com/dcarter
username : dcarter
bio : Laborum placeat eos et non. Esse possimus quis eveniet illum laudantium hic earum.
followers : 688
following : 1335